
Choosing UK workplace mental health benefits can look straightforward until the proposals arrive. One supplier sells a helpline and short-term counselling. Another offers therapy, coaching and a wellbeing app. A third provides a marketplace where employees choose their own specialist.
Each may promise better engagement and healthier teams. But those promises can describe very different services, costs and responsibilities.
A request for proposal, or RFP, gives HR and people leaders a consistent way to compare them. The aim is to understand what employees will actually receive, what happens when support is unsuitable, how confidentiality works and whether the arrangement fits your workforce.
This guide explains how to write the brief, assess evidence, test access and turn a mental health benefits comparison into a defensible buying decision.
Editorial disclosure: SympathiQ provides a wellbeing marketplace and employer wellbeing services. This guide reflects that perspective and applies the same evaluation questions to every supplier, including SympathiQ.
A workplace mental health benefits RFP asks suppliers to explain how they would meet your organisation’s support needs. It sets out the workforce, required services, budget assumptions, evidence requirements and scoring method.
A useful RFP does three things:
Makes offers comparable.
Exposes service gaps.
Creates commitments that can carry into the contract.
It is particularly helpful when replacing an employee assistance programme (EAP), expanding therapy access or assessing employee wellness marketplaces alongside existing UK employee benefits.
Smaller employers can use a short questionnaire and a structured demonstration. More complex purchases may need separate clinical, information security, commercial and implementation reviews.
Before approaching suppliers, agree what is missing today.
Are employees struggling to find appointments? Is support difficult for shift workers to access? Do people understand the difference between counselling and coaching? Is an existing benefit poorly communicated?
Build the brief around workforce needs:
Population: Eligible headcount, employment groups, locations and languages.
Working patterns: Shifts, remote work, travel and access to a private space.
Required support: Counselling, psychological therapy, coaching, manager training or a defined combination.
Funding: Employer-paid sessions, an allowance, employee payment or shared costs.
Existing provision: EAP, occupational health, insurance and internal support.
Success measures: Timely access, employee understanding, appropriate support and controlled spending.
Purchasing a platform does not remove the need to address harmful working conditions. HSE states that employers must assess work-related stress risks and act on them. Use its stress risk assessment guidance alongside your benefit strategy. HSE
Compare service models before comparing suppliersWorkplace wellbeing platforms can serve different purposes. Confirm the actual scope of each proposal; these categories describe common models rather than universal inclusions.
Model | Typical buying purpose | What to verify |
|---|---|---|
EAP | An initial support route, potentially including counselling and practical advice. | Eligibility, session limits, assessment and onward referral. |
Therapy-focused provider | Access to defined therapeutic interventions. | Clinical suitability, credentials, treatment limits and continuity. |
Wellbeing marketplace | Choice across therapists, coaches and other specialists. | Vetting by discipline, available appointments, funding and responsibility for care. |
Digital wellbeing platform | Self-guided resources, learning and everyday wellbeing tools. | Whether human support is included and what supports effectiveness claims. |
Occupational health service | Advice about health in relation to work. | Referral scope, consent processes and information supplied to the employer. |
A marketplace might complement an EAP by widening specialist choice. It does not automatically replace every EAP function.
For a related buying framework, see our UK employee mental health benefits marketplace scorecard.
Begin with who provides support and who is responsible when something goes wrong.
“Verified”, “qualified” and “accredited” describe different checks. Ask suppliers to explain each term.
Professional requirements differ by role. The HCPC regulates protected titles including clinical psychologist and counselling psychologist. “Therapist” and “counsellor” are not HCPC-protected titles. Check the HCPC explanation of professional regulation rather than assuming every practitioner has the same status. The HCPC
For counselling and psychotherapy, request details of relevant professional registration or accreditation, such as BACP or UKCP, and how current status is checked. Ask separately about coaching credentials and supervision arrangements.
Include these RFP questions:
Which qualifications, professional registrations and insurance do you require for each discipline?
How often are credentials rechecked, and what happens when they expire?
Who assesses suitability for therapy, coaching or another service?
What are the exclusion criteria, safeguarding process and escalation arrangements?
Who owns clinical governance, complaints and incident review?
Which entity contracts with the employee, provides the service and holds session records?
Require a clear distinction between clinical care and non-clinical support. Coaching should not be presented as an interchangeable substitute for treatment.
For an example of information buyers can review, see SympathiQ’s trust and safety information, then request supporting documentation during due diligence.
Employees need to know what their employer can see before they decide to use a benefit.
Health information is special category data. The ICO explains that processing it requires an Article 6 lawful basis and an Article 9 condition. Its guidance also highlights the difficulty of relying on consent in employment because of the power imbalance. Read the ICO guidance on workers’ health information when reviewing data arrangements. ico.org.uk
Your privacy review should cover the employer, platform, practitioners and subcontractors. Request a data-flow map identifying controller and processor roles for each activity. These roles may differ across eligibility checks, booking and clinical records.
Ask suppliers to provide:
Data collected, purposes, access permissions and retention periods.
Hosting and remote-access locations, subprocessors and international transfer arrangements.
Relevant contracts, employee privacy notices and security assurance evidence.
Incident notification commitments and data rights procedures.
A sample employer report, including invoices and downloadable exports.
Rules preventing identification through small groups, filters or repeated reports.
Aggregate reporting is not automatically anonymous. A small team, a narrow date range or a specialist category could make someone identifiable.
Ask your privacy lead to assess whether a data protection impact assessment is needed and whether the proposed reporting is proportionate.
Employees should receive a plain-English explanation of confidentiality and its limits, including safeguarding and legal disclosure situations.
A large practitioner directory does not guarantee a suitable appointment. Assess bookable capacity for your workforce rather than total network size.
Request recent waiting-time data with definitions, dates and exclusions. Distinguish time to initial assessment from time to the first therapeutic appointment. Ask for median and longer waits rather than an average alone.
Test three journeys during the demonstration:
A shift worker needs an evening appointment without using a work email address.
A remote employee wants to compare relevant specialists and change practitioner after a poor fit.
An employee working overseas needs confirmation that support is permitted and insured in their current location.
Check accessibility, mobile usability, language availability, time-zone handling, cancellation rules and follow-up appointments with the same practitioner.
“24/7 access” may mean a helpline or self-guided content. Require the supplier to identify exactly which service operates around the clock.
You can browse SympathiQ’s specialist directory to explore how practitioner choice is presented. Employer eligibility, funded access and service commitments should be confirmed separately.
A satisfaction score answers a different question from a clinical outcome measure.
App registrations do not demonstrate improved mental health. Changes in absence do not establish that a platform caused them.
For every significant outcome claim, request the evaluation, participant numbers, response rate, follow-up period and limitations. Establish whether the evidence concerns the service being proposed or a different product.
Supplier claim | Evidence to request |
|---|---|
Employees engage with the benefit. | Unique users and completed sessions, with eligible headcount and reporting period. |
Support improves wellbeing. | Appropriate outcome measures, baseline and follow-up results, and missing-data information. |
The service reduces absence. | Absence definitions, comparison method and other possible explanations. |
The service delivers a financial return. | Calculation method, full costs, assumptions and sensitivity analysis. |
For relevant digital health products, the NICE evidence standards framework offers a reference for evaluating evidence. It was developed for health and care decision-making; it is not a blanket certification for employer wellbeing platforms. NICE
If AI is involved, ask what it does, what data it receives, how outputs are checked and whether employees can access a human alternative. Request explicit terms covering the use of employee information for model training.
Effective employer wellness programs depend on communication and practical access as well as the service itself.
Ask who will explain the benefit, support managers and answer employee questions.
NICE’s mental wellbeing at work guidance considers organisational culture, managers and support for employees. Use that broader perspective when assessing where a platform fits within your workplace strategy. NICE
Request an implementation plan with named owners, dependencies and milestones.
Confirm whether eligibility management, single sign-on, integrations, branded pages and reporting are available now, optional extras or future developments.
Request references relevant to your organisation’s size and working patterns. A desk-based head-office launch may reveal little about access for employees in retail, hospitality or field roles.
A subscription covering limited counselling and a platform fee excluding appointments purchase different benefits.
Request a standard pricing schedule covering:
Platform charges and minimum spend.
Session prices, duration and assessments.
Employee contributions.
Implementation, reporting and training.
Cancellation and missed-appointment fees.
Annual increases and applicable VAT treatment.
Estimated annual cost = fixed charges + expected paid sessions × agreed session price + implementation and extras + applicable taxes.
Model low, expected and high use.
For pooled budgets, confirm what happens when funding runs out. For individual allowances, confirm eligibility, expiry and whether unused balances can be reassigned.
Review renewal deadlines, termination rights, service-level remedies and continuity for employees already receiving support.
Agree how eligibility data is removed while practitioner records are retained under the applicable requirements.
These weights are an illustrative procurement framework rather than an industry standard. Adjust them before inviting proposals.
Criterion | Weight | Evidence to review |
|---|---|---|
Clinical quality and safety | 25% | Credentials, governance, safeguarding and referrals. |
Privacy and security | 20% | Data flows, contracts, assurance evidence and sample reports. |
Employee access and suitability | 20% | Booking tests, waiting times, accessibility and continuity. |
Evidence and measurement | 15% | Evaluation methods, outcome definitions and limitations. |
Workforce fit and implementation | 10% | Launch plan, support arrangements and relevant references. |
Commercial value and terms | 10% | Comparable cost scenarios, commitments and exit plan. |
Score each category from 0 to 5:
0: No acceptable response.
1: Unsupported claim.
2: Partial evidence.
3: Requirement met.
4: Well-supported delivery.
5: Compelling evidence of additional value relevant to your workforce.
Weighted points = category score ÷ 5 × category weight.
A score of 4 for a category weighted at 25% contributes 20 points to the total out of 100.
Set mandatory gates separately. An unacceptable safety process, unresolved privacy risk or inability to serve the eligible workforce should prevent appointment regardless of the overall score.
Ask each supplier to answer these questions in the same order and attach supporting evidence:
Describe the services included, exclusions and intended employee population.
Identify the entities responsible for service delivery, clinical governance and records.
Provide practitioner qualification, registration, insurance and rechecking requirements.
Explain suitability assessment, safeguarding, escalation and onward referral.
Supply recent appointment availability and waiting-time data with definitions.
Demonstrate booking, practitioner choice, switching and follow-up access.
Confirm accessibility, languages, working hours and geographic restrictions.
Provide a data-flow map, privacy documentation and security evidence.
Show exactly what employers receive through reports, invoices and exports.
Explain outcome measures and substantiate significant effectiveness claims.
Provide an implementation plan, service levels and relevant references.
Quote all costs and explain renewal, termination and continuity arrangements.
Require suppliers to label every capability as included and available now, available at extra cost, planned or not offered.
This helps prevent a roadmap feature from being scored as an existing service.
A defined pilot can test communication, booking access, budget controls and the usefulness of reporting.
Agree success criteria and the review date before launch. Measure awareness, unique users, completed appointments, waiting times, voluntary feedback and spending.
Investigate access barriers without identifying employees who seek support.
A short pilot can reveal operational problems. It may not establish sustained clinical improvement or a reliable financial return, particularly with a small workforce. Evaluate it against the questions it can reasonably answer.
SympathiQ connects people with therapists, coaches and wellbeing specialists for online sessions. For employers exploring specialist choice and broader wellbeing support, its marketplace model is an option to assess alongside existing benefits.
Review SympathiQ for companies and request a proposal specifying the service scope, practitioner standards, appointment access, funding arrangements, reporting and contractual responsibilities relevant to your workforce.
Apply the same scorecard to SympathiQ as to every other supplier. Confirm required capabilities and commitments in writing before making a decision.
Planning an employer wellbeing benefit? Contact SympathiQ to discuss your workforce and request a tailored proposal.
Include workforce needs, service scope, practitioner standards, safeguarding, privacy, appointment access, evidence, implementation, reporting, pricing and contract terms. Ask every supplier to use the same response format and attach evidence.
An EAP commonly provides an initial support route that may include counselling and practical advice. A marketplace commonly lets employees choose among practitioners and specialisms. Inclusions vary, so compare the actual services and responsibilities in each proposal.
That depends on the service and its data arrangements. Specify confidentiality requirements, review every employer-facing output and establish what identifiable information, if any, is shared and why. Aggregate reports also need safeguards against re-identification.
Ask suppliers to distinguish initial contact, assessment and the first suitable therapeutic appointment. Request recent data, typical and longer waits, and availability for relevant specialisms, languages and working hours.
It can replace some functions or complement an existing service, depending on the contract. Check counselling, urgent support, practical advice, referrals and continuity individually before removing another benefit.
Use a proportionate questionnaire, test the employee journey and model total costs at different usage levels. A pilot can help assess access and operational fit without assuming that early usage proves long-term health outcomes.
This guide supports procurement planning and does not replace legal, data protection or clinical advice for a specific service arrangement.
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *